THE NAUTICAL CHARTS OF PIRI REIS

Ottoman Turkish map making really begins with Piri
Reis, and this is no faltering start as might be expected, but a
spectacular debut. His Kitab-i Bahriye (Book of Navigation) is a
portalan or manual of maps showing every cove, harbour and island
in the Mediterranean in unprecedented detail. Piri Reis also drew
two maps of outstanding importance in the history of mapmaking,
one of the world and another of North America, whose accuracy and
projection system were extraordinary for their time.
As well as cartographer and navigator, Piri Reis was a commander
who left his mark on Ottoman naval history. He was born sometime
between 1465 and 1470 in Gelibolu (Gallipoli), a town on the strait
linking the Marmara Sea to the Aegean where the inhabitants had
been seafarers for many generations. He owed his own place in Ottoman
nautical history to his uncle Kemal Reis, a famous Turkish corsair
and admiral who was feared throughout the Mediterranean during the
last quarter of the 15th century.
Until 1492, Piri Reis served with Kemal Reis on
his pirating expeditions along the coasts of Spain in the western
Mediterranean. At the request of Sultan Bayezid II (1481-1512),
Piri Reis and Kemal Reis abandoned piracy to enter the Ottoman as
naval service, and naval commanders they took part in the sea battles
of Lepanto, Methoni, Koroni, Navarino, Mitylene and Rhodes.
When Kemal Reis died in 1510, Piri Reis returned
to Gelibolu, where he began work on his Book of Navigation. In 1517
he returned to sea to serve as admiral in the Egyptian campaign
of Selim I, and it was then that he presented the world map which
he had completed in 1513 to the sultan. During this period he also
accompanied his cousin Muhiddin Reis, one of Barbaros Hayrettin
Pasa's captains, on campaigns in the Mediterranean. He subsequently
spent several years in Gelibolu working on the maps and text for
his Book of Navigation.
He completed this work in 1526, and presented it
to Sultan Süleyman the Magnificent. When he finished his map
of North America in 1528 he presented this to the same sultan.Piri
Reis's final period of active service with the Ottoman Navy was
as Commander of Egypt, an episode which ended in tragedy. After
his second campaign against the Portuguese in 1552, he left his
fleet in Basra for repairs, and sailed with three ships filled with
spoils of war to Egypt. Here he was imprisoned and unjustly condemned
to death for failure to perform his duty by governor of Egypt Mehmed
Pasa, incited by Kubat Pasa, governor of Basra, whose enmity Piri
Reis had aroused by refusing to cede a share of the spoils. He was
over 80 years old when he died, and his estate was seized by the
authorities.

Piri Reis's world map was discovered at Topkapi
Palace in 1929 by Halil Edhem Eldem, director of National Museums.
The map was examined by the German orientalist, Prof Paul Kahle,
who was engaged in research in Istanbul at the time,
and Kahle reported on the map to the eighteenth Congress
of Oriental Studies in Leiden in 1931. Meanwhile, the map was taken
to Ankara, where it was examined by historians, and Atatürk ordered
a facsimile reproduction of the map to be printed.
The map is drawn on camel skin, with illustrations in nine different
colours. It is 86 cm long, 61 cm wide at the upper edge, and 41
cm wide at the lower edge. Close examination shows that the right-hand
section of the map has been torn away, although the discrepancy
in width between the upper and lower edges is due to the natural
shape of the skin. The surviving half of the map shows the east
and west coasts of the Atlantic Ocean. The coastlines of North and
South America, the Antilles, northwest Africa, Spain and France
correspond closely to modern maps. The map is a typical nautical
chart, with compass roses and lines showing direction in place of
lines of latitude and longitude. It is decorated with mythical and
realistic pictures, including a number of ships.
As well as placed names, the chart is annotated with dates of discovery,
legends about the places shown, and explanations of how the map
was compiled. The beautifully executed decoration confirms that
the map was drawn as a gift for the Ottoman sultan. There are five
compass roses on the map, three small and two large.
The lines of writing on the northwest section of South America
read, "The humble Piri, son of Haci Mehmed, and renowned as
the nephew of Kemal Reis, composed this map in the town of Gallipoli
in the holy month of Muharrem 919 [1513]. May God absolve them both."
Piri Reis reveals the sources which he used for his map with the
honesty of a scholar, as we see in the notes over South America:
"This section states the way in which this map was drawn. I
have used twenty maps and mappae mundi dating from the time of Alexander
the Great showing the lands inhabited by men. The Arab people refer
to those maps as caferiye.
As well as eight caferiye of that kind, I have made use of one
Arabic map of India and four modern Portuguese maps, some of which
delineate the lands of Sind, India and China according to geometrical
methods, and one map drawn by Columbus in the western lands. By
reducing all these maps to one scale this form was arrived at. So
that the present map is as correct and reliable for the seven seas
as the map of our countries is considered correct and reliable by
seamen." Above this is an account of the discovery of the American
continent, ending with a further acknowledgement of the fact that
his map was based on that of Christopher Columbus: "Whatever
shores and islands are shown on the map in question have been taken
from the map of Christopher Columbus." This is one of the most
fascinating aspects of the map, since although Christopher Columbus
is known to have made maps of the coasts during his four voyages
to America between 1492 and 1504, none of them have survived. They
live on only in the map drawn by Piri Reis.
The world map drawn by Juan de la Cosa, who accompanied Columbus
as guide on his second voyage, dated 1500, that of Contari dated
1506, and of Martin Waldseemuller dated 1507 are the earliest maps
of America, and Waldseemuller's is the first to show the American
continent as separate from Asia. However, Piri Reis's map is more
accurate than any of these.
The perfection of Piri Reis's projection is the map's most outstanding
feature. A study by Prof. C.Hapgood in 1965 has demonstrated an
extraordinary correlation between Piri Reis's map and a map based
on aerial photographs taking Cairo as the central point. Erich Von
Däniken, in his book Chariots of the Gods, makes the sensational
claim that the map must have been drawn from photographs taken from
spacecraft.
The depiction of mountains in Antactica poses a particular enigma
since the mountains are invisible under layers of ice, and their
existence only became apparent after scientists conducted experiments
using soundwaves in 1951.
In short, the map of Piri Reis is the most accurate of all those
made in the wake of Columbus's discovery of America, and the closest
to modern maps.
During the unsuccessful search for the missing section of Piri Reis's
world map, Director of Topkapi Palace Museum, Tahsin Öz, came
across a second map measuring 69 by 70 centimetres. Drawn on gazelle
skin in eight colours, this is a typical nautical chart and similar
in style to the first, although more meticulously executed. Again
this is only a fragment of the original map. The ornately decorated
border remains along the north and west edges, and the annotation
along the other edges is broken off where the other sections have
been removed. The remaining section shows the northern Atlantic
and the coasts of North and Central America, and bears four large
ornate and two smaller compass roses. The two scales are in miles,
and below them is an explanatory note to the effect that each division
represents ten miles.
Beneath the vertical scale are four lines telling us the date of
the map: 'The humble Piri Reis, son of Haci Mehmed and nephew of
the late Captain Gazi Kemal of Gelibolu, completed this in the year
935 [1528]. This is his work.' This signature inscription is in
Arabic, but all the other annotations on the map are in Turkish.
It has been claimed that this is a world map like the first, but
in my opinion this cannot be the case, since the scale is too large.
Almost certainly the missing sections extended to Antarctica in
the south and to Istanbul in the east. It appears that Piri Reis
wished to show the Ottoman capital in relation to the New World
on a large scale map. Another objective was perhaps to present Sultan
Süleyman with a map updated in the light of new discoveries.
Alternatively it may have been that the Ottoman palace commissioned
him to draw this map. The fact that some of the imaginary islands
which appear on the first map are not shown here, that the coast
of America is more accurately delineated, and that the mythical
illustrations and legends included on the first map are now absent
demonstrate that over the intervening fifteen years Piri Reis had
kept up with the findings of explorers. The Tropic of Cancer is
drawn (with a very small degree of error), so we may deduce that
the Equator and the Tropic of Capricorn were shown on the missing
sections. He also avoids the practice on portolan charts of exaggerating
the scale of harbours so as to provide additional detail for sailors.
Evidently he was concerned to produce a map which was more accurate
and up to date than the earlier one.
Piri Reis's Book of Navigation is a subject of equal fascination,
but one of such broad scope that it must be reserved for a future
article.
* Kemal Özdemir is a researcher and author
Articles
Index
|